So with Murphy coming off his best game of the year Wednesday afternoon in Chicago, Collins hopes that performance will give him enough confidence simply to stop tinkering.
"This game is so psychological with the confidence factor," Collins said Thursday, "that when you're up at home plate and you're swinging the bat good, you're saying, 'OK, yeah, I've gotten where I want to be' -- when you haven't done anything except battle through it. There's not really anything ever changed except your mental outlook. In Dan's case, we've always known he can hit. We've told him he can hit. We just told him to relax, let all those physical gifts come into play. And yesterday I thought was a good breakout day for him."
Collins knows that he cannot stop Murphy from tinkering when things go awry -- not that he would want to, anyway. Attention to detail is one of the reasons Murphy was able to work himself from a 13th-round Draft pick to a Major League regular; discouraging that type of work ethic could be counterproductive.
But tinkering or not, Murphy finally appears to be on the upswing following an 8-for-61 (.131) stretch with just two extra-base hits earlier this month. The second baseman has four extra-base hits over his last four games, including his first two home runs of the season on Wednesday.
As a result, Collins started him at second base Thursday against Dodgers left-hander Chris Capuano, despite a hesitance to play Murphy against lefties throughout the latter half of his slump. Murphy should receive his only off-day this weekend Sunday against left-hander Clayton Kershaw, the reigning National League Cy Young Award winner.
"We all know when Dan's swinging good, he's dangerous," Collins said. "Not that he hits homers, but he's a dangerous hitter. So we hope that this is a stepping-stone certainly for him to get better."